Under what circumstances can a luxury brand prohibit an unauthorized seller from selling its perfumes?

In principle, a trademark owner cannot prevent the resale of its products once it has placed them on the market itself within the European Economic Area. Nevertheless, on February 23, 2026, the Bergen Court of Appeals prohibited the drugstore chain Kruidvat from selling Dior perfumes online, even though Kruidvat had not even been allowed to present evidence that the trademark rights had been exhausted. The reason: the way Kruidvat presented the perfumes—with bright colors, bargain prices, and without expert advice—seriously undermined the luxury image of the Dior brand. And that serious undermining is sufficient in itself to require the sales to be halted.

The facts

Parfums Christian Dior is the owner of the Benelux word marks Dior, Christian Dior, Miss Dior, and J’Adore. For the sale of its perfumes and cosmetics, Dior operates a selective distribution network within the European Economic Area: only authorized distributors who meet quality criteria are permitted to sell the products. For online sales, an internet addendum to the distribution contract imposes additional requirements.

Kruidvat is not an authorized Dior retailer. Since 2002, the chain has been part of the A.S. Watson Group, which does include authorized Dior retailers, such as Ici Paris XL. In April 2018, Dior discovered that Kruidvat was offering Dior products on kruidvat.be. A registered letter of formal notice was sent on April 30, 2018. Kruidvat removed the products from its website, but in November 2020, it once again advertised Dior products for Black Friday.

After that, the correspondence stalled on one point: Kruidvat was willing to provide confidential evidence that the products had been marketed in the European Economic Area with Dior’s permission, but refused to disclose the name of its supplier. On September 15, 2022, Dior sued Kruidvat in commercial court. On April 12, 2024, the court issued an injunction against online sales, imposing a penalty of 5,000 euros per day for each prohibited advertisement or sales offer and 500 euros per product offered. Kruidvat filed an appeal on June 4, 2024.

The ruling

Why the serious damage to the brand rendered the question of exhaustion moot

Kruidvat based its defense on the exhaustion of trademark rights. According to Article 2.23, § 3 of the Benelux Convention on Intellectual Property (BVIE) a trademark owner cannot prohibit the use of its trademark on products that it, or someone with its consent, has placed on the market in the Union. That provision is set forth in Article 15 of the Trademark Directive However, there is one exception to this rule: the trademark owner may still object to further sales if he has a valid reason to do so.

The Bergen Court of Appeals invoked that exception to avoid addressing the issue of exhaustion itself. Since the Dior/Evora decision (ECJ, November 4, 1997, C-337/95) it is established that serious damage to the brand’s reputation can constitute such a valid reason. A reseller of luxury products may use the forms of advertising that are customary in its own sector, but it must ensure that its advertising does not detract from the allure, the image of prestige, and the sense of luxury associated with the products. In the Copad v. Dior ruling (ECJ, April 23, 2009, C-59/08) The Court of Justice added that, in the case of prestige products, that sense of luxury is part of the product’s quality itself.

The Court of Appeals adopted the findings of the trial court in their entirety. Kruidvat’s web pages displayed the Dior perfumes alongside handbags and underwear without any recognizable luxury appeal. The marketing focused on bright yellow and red colors, crossed-out prices, and slogans such as “Superdeluxe Deals” and “Beautiful Luxury Deal,” giving the impression that only the price mattered. Furthermore, Kruidvat did not offer any form of specialized advice. Each element on its own might not have been sufficient, the Court of Appeals acknowledged, but taken together, they seriously undermined the brand’s luxury image. Once that damage had been established, it was no longer necessary to examine whether Kruidvat could provide proof of exhaustion.

Why the Court of Appeals Did Not Refer a Question for a Preliminary Ruling to the Court of Justice

Kruidvat requested, in the alternative, that the Court of Justice clarify which criteria apply when a third-party seller’s advertising is customary in its own sector but differs from that of the authorized distributors. The Court of Appeals refused. The Court of Justice has already interpreted Article 15 of the Trademark Directive on numerous occasions, and it follows from that case law that whether there is serious infringement is a question of fact to be assessed by the national court itself. Kruidvat had also submitted a similar German ruling by the Düsseldorf Court of Appeals dated June 29, 2023, in which a discount flyer featuring perfume offers was deemed acceptable. That, too, was to no avail: that court ruled on a different brochure, which was not even submitted in the Belgian proceedings.

Why the strike action and the penalty without a cap remained in effect

Kruidvat considered the injunction too vague and asked the Court of Appeals to determine for itself under what conditions it would be permitted to promote Dior products—for example, using subdued colors and without conspicuous crossed-out prices. The Court of Appeals also rejected that request: it is not up to the court to define, in the abstract, marketing criteria that preserve the luxury image. The court held that the cease-and-desist order—which prohibits sales unless the conditions safeguarding the luxury nature of the products are met—was sufficiently precise and proportionate.

Nor was the requested cap of 50,000 euros on the penalty payments granted. Kruidvat is a major player in a vast market spanning Belgium and the Netherlands, and in the absence of figures on typical sales volumes, it was not possible to determine a reasonable upper limit. The initial judgment was upheld on all counts.

Why Dior's claim for third-party liability for breach of contract failed

Dior had filed an appeal on its own initiative. The trial court had dismissed its claim, which was based on the doctrine of third-party complicity: by sourcing its supplies from an authorized distributor that was contractually prohibited from supplying third parties, Kruidvat had allegedly knowingly participated in a breach of contract, which constitutes an unfair market practice within the meaning of Article VI.104 of the Code of Economic Law (WER).

The Court of Appeals upheld the dismissal, citing a ruling by the Court of Cassation dated December 3, 2021 (C.20.0433.F). According to that ruling, knowingly participating in a violation of a sales prohibition under a selective distribution agreement is, as a general rule, not a valid ground for setting aside the doctrine of exhaustion. The claim of unfair competition therefore cannot be examined separately from the trademark infringement: it succeeds only when the product is a luxury item, the prohibition protects the brand’s reputation, and the method of sale effectively damages that reputation. This is precisely the same test as for the trademark infringement itself.

Legal analysis and interpretation

The distribution contract is not binding on third parties, but it does provide a benchmark

Kruidvat never entered into a contract with Dior, and yet its online store was evaluated against the requirements set forth in Dior’s e-retail contract: a well-maintained e-commerce environment, no sales techniques that undermine the brand’s prestige, and a sufficiently large and qualified advisory team. This appears to contradict the Coty Germany ruling (Court of Justice of the European Union, December 6, 2017, C-230/16), in which the Court of Justice ruled that a supplier cannot impose the quality requirements set forth in its distribution contracts on a contractual basis on parties with whom it has no contract.

The Bergen Court of Appeals untangles this issue with a subtle distinction. The question is not whether Kruidvat breached the contract, because that contract is not binding on it. The question is whether its sales practices damage the brand. And to determine what requirements are necessary to maintain the luxury image, the court is permitted to examine the distribution contract, because, according to the Copad/Dior ruling, the characteristics of a selective distribution system can, in and of themselves, guarantee the quality of the products. The contract therefore does not function as a binding obligation, but rather as evidence of what is required to maintain the luxury image. The court of appeals did, however, add a caveat: brand infringement cannot be inferred from the mere fact that an outsider does not fully comply with the quality requirements. An overall factual assessment remains necessary.

According to the Court of Appeals, expert advice also counts online

The most striking sentence in the ruling concerns staff. In its closing arguments, Kruidvat had admitted that the presence of specialized sales staff online could “to a certain extent” contribute to a brand’s luxury image, but argued that the lack of expert advice did not constitute a serious detriment. The Court of Appeals ruled otherwise: advice from competent and specialized staff remains relevant, even in online commerce. Anyone who sells luxury products online without any form of specialized guidance thereby contributes an element that, together with others, can constitute a serious impairment.

That consideration deserves the attention of every online store that deals with the trademark rights comes into contact with. The traditional duty to provide advice from brick-and-mortar perfume stores is extended here to the internet, where it can take the form, for example, of a chat function with trained staff or comprehensive product guidance. The Court of Appeals does, however, immediately qualify this: the mere absence of advice might not be sufficient. The infringement resulted from the overall context, including the brochures and the product environment.

Unfair competition in Belgium does not provide a way around exhaustion

The dismissal of Dior’s incidental appeal completes the picture. Prior to the Court of Cassation’s ruling of December 3, 2021, trademark owners attempted to circumvent the doctrine of exhaustion through the theory of third-party complicity: after all, anyone who knowingly cooperates in another party’s breach of contract commits a unfair market practice, the suspension of which may be ordered, as the Court of Cassation previously confirmed in a judgment dated May 28, 2020 (C.18.0011.N). However, since the 2021 ruling, it has been established that, as a general rule, this avenue is closed when trademark rights have been exhausted: only unfair conduct that infringes upon the specific subject matter of the trademark right itself can overcome exhaustion.

The result is strict symmetry. For ordinary products, the trademark owner cannot prevent sales by a party outside the network, not even indirectly through Book VI of the WER. For luxury products, this is possible, but only when the specific method of sale seriously damages the reputation, and in that case, the trademark law route is immediately the only one that matters. One caveat: an appeal in cassation against the judgment is pending, so the final word on this case has not yet been spoken.

Specifically, what does this mean?

For owners of luxury brands. Document the requirements set forth in your selective distribution agreement regarding product presentation, the sales environment, and product advice, including for e-commerce. It was precisely these contractual criteria that served as the benchmark in this case to demonstrate the serious infringement by an outsider. In addition, gather concrete evidence of the disputed sales practices: screenshots of the product pages, promotional brochures, and the lack of an advisory function made all the difference in this case. Do not rely on third-party complicity as a separate basis for a claim: without reputational damage to a luxury product, such a claim will fail following the Supreme Court ruling of December 3, 2021.

For discount retailers and online stores that sell brand-name products outside the network. Exhaustion of trademark rights is no free pass. Even if you can prove that the products were placed on the market in the European Economic Area with the trademark owner’s consent, you remain vulnerable as soon as your sales methods seriously undermine the product’s luxury image. When it comes to luxury products, avoid the combination that proved fatal here: garish colors, heavily discounted prices, run-of-the-mill knockoffs, and a complete lack of expert advice. Also be aware that the penalty can be substantial: in this case, 5,000 euros per day and 500 euros per product, with no upper limit. Anyone who wants to assess in advance whether their sales model is viable should seek assistance from a lawyer specializing in trademark law.

Frequently asked questions (FAQ)

Can I resell brand-name products that I purchased legally myself?
In principle, yes. Once the trademark owner has placed the products on the market in the European Economic Area—either directly or with his consent—his trademark rights are exhausted, and he cannot prohibit further sales. However, the burden of proof regarding such exhaustion rests with the seller. And for luxury goods, there is an important exception: the trademark owner may still object if your method of sale seriously damages the brand’s reputation.

What does the exhaustion of a trademark right mean?
Exhaustion means that the trademark owner has exhausted its exclusive right to a specific copy of the product by placing that copy on the market within the Union. After that, that item may be freely resold. This rule is set forth in Article 2.23, § 3 of the BVIE and protects the free movement of goods. Exhaustion applies on a per-item basis: for products intended for markets outside the European Economic Area, trademark rights remain in full force.

Can a trademark owner require an online store to provide expert advice?
Not directly, because an online store that does not have a contract with the brand owner is not bound by the quality requirements of the distribution network. However, according to the Court of Appeals in Bergen, the absence of any form of specialized advice can indeed be considered one of the factors that, taken together, constitute serious damage to a luxury brand, even in the case of purely online sales.

Conclusion

The February 23, 2026, ruling by the Bergen Court of Appeals confirms how limited the scope is in Belgium for selling luxury products outside the selective distribution network. The exhaustion of trademark rights protects the reseller only as long as their sales methods respect the brand’s luxury image, and the requirements set forth in the distribution contract serve as the benchmark in this regard—even against parties who never signed that contract. Expert advice remains relevant in this context, including online. The opposite lesson applies to trademark owners: outside the luxury segment, neither trademark law nor the doctrine of third-party liability offers a defense against sales outside the network.


Joris Deene

Mr. Joris Deene is a partner at Everest Attorneys and heads the department of intellectual property, IT law, AI law, data protection, and media law. ICT Legal Guide is that department’s knowledge platform. Joris publishes and teaches on copyright law, trademark law, software law, the GDPR, the AI Act, the DSA, and media law.

Contact

Questions? Need advice?
Contact Attorney Joris Deene.

Phone: 09/280.20.68
E-mail: joris.deene@everest-law.be

Topics