Not with a blanket ban, ruled the Conseil constitutionnel, the French Constitutional Court, on August 14, 2026. France was the first EU member state to pass a law banning social media for children under the age of 15, but the key provision of that law was struck down before it took effect (Constitutional Councill August 14, 2026, No. 2026-911 DC). The decision is also relevant to Belgium: the exact same debate is raging here, and the French reasoning highlights the legal pitfalls that any Belgian or European regulation will have to navigate.
The facts
On July 21, 2026, the French Parliament passed a law to protect minors from the risks of social media. Article 1 of that law added Articles 6 through 9 to the French Act of June 21, 2004, on the Digital Economy. That new provision, in principle, prohibited minors under the age of 15 from accessing online social networking services provided by online platforms. The ban would apply to new accounts starting September 1, 2026, and to existing accounts starting January 2027.
The statistics behind the law are striking. According to the French media regulator Arcom, French children between the ages of 12 and 17 spend an average of 1 hour and 21 minutes a day on TikTok alone. The legislature sought to protect the youngest users from addiction, isolation, pornography, bullying, and fraud.
Two groups, each consisting of more than sixty members of parliament, submitted the bill to the Constitutional Council on July 23 and 24, 2026; in France, the Constitutional Council has the authority to review laws before they are enacted. They argued that a blanket ban—which makes no distinction between platforms and assigns no role to parents—violates minors’ freedom of speech. The decision was handed down three weeks later.
The ruling
The Constitutional Council based its decision on Article 11 of the the 1789 Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, which guarantees the free exchange of ideas and opinions. Given the role that online services play in democratic life today, the freedom of speech , according to the court, also includes the right to access those services and to express oneself on them. Restrictions must be necessary, appropriate, and proportionate to the intended purpose.
The Constitutional Council did not question the legislature’s objectives. Protecting children from addiction, isolation, pornography, bullying, and fraud fulfills the constitutional requirement to safeguard the best interests of the child and the objective of preventing breaches of public order. These objectives can justify restricting access for minors. The problem lay in the implementation.
First, the ban applied to any platform that allows users to connect, communicate with one another, share content, and discover other users or content. The law did not impose any conditions regarding the functions or content of the service, the risks it poses, or the protection it already provides. The exceptions were limited to online encyclopedias, educational or scientific directories, and open-source platforms. Thus, services for leisure, information, or mutual assistance; communication apps; online games with social features; and social networks linked to educational activities also fell outside these exceptions. As a result, the ban could affect services for which no risk to the health or safety of minors has been established.
Second, the ban affected all children under the age of fifteen in exactly the same way. No provision allowed parents or legal guardians, in the best interests of the child, to lift the ban, limit its scope, or grant access to certain services. The law did not take into account the child’s age, maturity, or family situation, nor the nature of the service in question. The Constitutional Council ruled that, without disregarding freedom of expression, the legislature could not impose a blanket ban that denies minors access to numerous online services without any consideration for the child’s situation or the risks posed by the service.
On top of that came the right to respect for private life. Anyone who prohibits access by individuals under the age of fifteen effectively requires everyone—including adults—to prove their age before they can use the platform. However, the law did not specify any conditions or limits for such proof of age and contained no legal safeguards for privacy. Article 1 also fell short in this regard. The Constitutional Council declared the provision in its entirety to be contrary to the French Constitution, without even examining the other grounds for review.
Legal analysis and interpretation
Would a Belgian ban stand up to scrutiny by the Constitutional Court?
In Belgium, the same proposal was on the table at the end of 2025. The political parties Vooruit and CD&V advocated for a ban on social media for children under 16, but in December 2025, the Flemish Government chose with the "Safe Online" Action Plan an alternative approach: an effectively enforced minimum age of 13, measures to address addictive algorithms such as infinite scrolling, and a ban on personalized advertising targeting minors. If a Belgian ban is ever enacted, it will only be reviewed after the fact. Unlike the Conseil constitutionnel, which reviews laws before they are enacted, the Belgian Constitutional Court only rules after the law has entered into force, in response to an appeal for annulment or a request for a preliminary ruling.
The standard of review would, however, be very similar. Article 19 of the Constitution guarantees the freedom to express one’s opinion in any field, and the Constitutional Court interprets that provision in conjunction with Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), which imposes the same tests of necessity and proportionality that the French court applied in this case. It is also noteworthy that Article 19 of the Constitution permits only retroactive punishment for offenses committed in the exercise of that freedom. A ban that precludes access in advance and for everyone thus raises an additional question in Belgium that was not even addressed in France: is such a preventive measure compatible with the repressive system of our Constitution?
In Belgium, too, the best interests of the child have two aspects, just as in the French decision. Article 22bis of the Constitution makes that best interest the primary consideration in any decision affecting the child, but the same article grants every child the right to express their opinion, which must be taken into account in accordance with their age and capacity for discernment. A ban that treats a 12-year-old and a 14-year-old identically—and that deprives parents of any discretion—is at odds with precisely that gradation. In Belgium, this is further complicated by the division of powers: media policy falls under the jurisdiction of the communities, while economic law and criminal law are federal matters, so it must first be determined who is even authorized to impose such a ban.
Why Europe leaves little room for national bans
The French law was already in tatters before the Constitutional Council got involved. The French Council of State warned in its Opinion dated January 8, 2026 that requirements for platforms to block minors may conflict with the Digital Services Act (DSA), because member states may not impose obligations on online platforms beyond what is already provided for in that regulation. The sponsors therefore amended the text: the prohibition was directed at the minor themselves, not at the platform. In its detailled opinion of July 6, 2026 the European Commission ultimately objected to provisions that would have created a parallel national supervisory regime alongside the DSA, after which Parliament further weakened the enforcement framework.
What remained was a ban without its own enforcement mechanism, and even that did not hold up under the Constitution. The lesson extends beyond France. Article 28 of the DSA adopts a risk-based approach: platforms accessible to minors must take appropriate and proportionate measures to ensure a high level of privacy, safety, and security for minors. The Guidelines of July 14, 2025 of the European Commission specify that requirement by platform type, risk, and function. The Constitutional Council arrives at exactly the same philosophy through constitutional means: the problem is not the category of social media itself, but rather the specific risks posed by a specific service to a specific child. Anyone in Europe who wants to establish an age limit will therefore have to structure it according to risk profile, as the French Senate had initially proposed—with a blacklist of harmful platforms and parental consent required for the rest. That tiered approach did not make it into the final text.
Age verification remains a weak point, even in Belgium
The second stumbling block deserves at least as much attention as the first. An age limit only works if age is verified, and that verification affects everyone. The Constitutional Council put it bluntly: the ban also requires every adult to prove their age. A legislator who wishes to do so must establish the conditions and limits of such proof and build in legal safeguards for privacy. They must not pass this responsibility on to the platforms.
This is a lesson that Belgium can apply directly. The minimum age here is currently 13: Article 7 of the Act of July 30, 2018 determines, pursuant to Article 8 of the General Data Protection Regulation that a child may only consent to the processing of their personal data when information society services are offered directly to them starting at age 13. Below that age, the consent of the legal representative is required. The Flemish “Safe Online” action plan aims to finally ensure compliance with precisely this existing age limit. In the Opinion No. 9877 of the Superior Health Council , the panel took this approach: a majority of the experts saw no merit in a total ban for those under 13, due to a lack of scientific evidence and significant practical challenges, and those who, based on the precautionary principle, still wish to restrict access for those under that age should, according to the same advice, acknowledge the limitations and potential unintended consequences of such a restriction.
Meanwhile, the European Union is working on a response to the data protection objection. With the Recommendation (EU) 2026/1035 of April 29, 2026, the Commission calls on Member States to make an age verification solution available by December 31, 2026, based on anonymous proofs of age: the user demonstrates that they meet an age threshold without revealing their exact age or identity. Such a double-blind system, linked to the European digital identity wallet, addresses the concern that platforms would have to process ID cards or biometric data from the entire population. The French decision is accelerating the pressure to finalize this tool: as long as it isn’t in place, every national age limit will fall victim to privacy concerns.
Specifically, what does this mean?
For Belgian lawmakers and policymakers. A total ban based on the French model is the weakest option from a legal standpoint. Anyone who wants to protect minors would be better off building on three approaches that do hold up: maintaining the existing age limit of 13 set forth in Article 7 of the Act of July 30, 2018; the risk-based obligations under Article 28 of the DSA against addictive design choices; and a legally regulated, privacy-friendly age verification system based on the European model. Any potential ban must be differentiated by type of service and by risk, with an explicit role for parents and with the conditions for age verification specified in the law itself.
For platforms and online service providers. The overturning of the French ban does not grant a free pass. The obligations under Article 28 of the DSA and the guidelines of July 14, 2025, remain fully in effect, and the Commission actively uses them as a benchmark. Anyone offering a service accessible to minors should already be conducting a risk assessment within the framework of media law and data protection law: which features pose risks to minors, what age verification measures are proportionate, and how can the collection of data be minimized.
For parents and schools. Under the law, the initial assessment rests with you today. The French ruling confirms that this parental role is not a matter of tolerance but a power enshrined in fundamental rights: the government may not completely sideline parents, and conversely, the guidance provided to the child—tailored to the child’s age and maturity—remains the standard by which judges also measure such cases.
Frequently asked questions (FAQ)
Is there a legal minimum age for social media in Belgium?
There is no minimum age requirement, such as the one France sought to introduce. However, a child may only consent to the processing of their personal data by online services once they reach the age of 13 (Article 7 of the Act of July 30, 2018). For children under 13, consent from a parent or legal guardian is required. Since December 2025, the Flemish Government has been focusing on the effective enforcement of this age limit, rather than on a ban.
Can an EU member state ban social media for young people?
This is doubly difficult. At the national level, a general ban conflicts with freedom of expression and the right to privacy, as illustrated by French Decision No. 2026-911 DC. At the European level, a member state may not impose obligations on online platforms beyond those set forth in the Digital Services Act, which itself adopts a risk-based approach. A differentiated regulatory framework involving parental consent and legally regulated age verification is more likely to succeed than a total ban.
Why is age verification such a legally sensitive issue?
Because an age limit for minors only works if everyone proves their age—including adults. That verification requires data processing on a population-wide scale, with risks of data breaches and identity linking. The European Commission is therefore developing a system of anonymous age verification, which allows a user to demonstrate that they meet an age threshold without revealing their identity. Member states are required to make such a solution available by December 31, 2026.
Conclusion
The French Constitutional Council struck down the European Union’s first blanket social media ban because it did not distinguish between platforms, did not take into account the child’s age and maturity, completely sidelined parents, and left age verification without any legal safeguards. For Belgium, the decision confirms that the protection of minors online follows a risk-based approach: maintaining the age of consent at 13, the platform obligations under the DSA, and a legally regulated, anonymous proof of age. Under Belgian law, a total ban would also conflict with freedom of expression and the right to privacy.



